What a great effect for only 3 mana! And that's not much of a downside in blue, these days anyway (I never saw this played back in the day but I mostly played in "kitchen magic" back then).

But I'm only rating 4 out of 5 because his arms... don't... look right. They look too long! Especially his right arm; the elbow looks too low for the way he is holding it. His legs also look too short. Look at where his left knee is, and where his left foot is, and how narrow and twisted around the legs are. It's like the lower half of his legs are too long and narrow compared to his body, and he's got his legs awfully flat despite sitting on his feet.

I don't know, maybe it's just the slightly askew tunic throwing me off.