I don't see why we're massively giving this a 1/5. In the days of legends, this was just a very decent card, as it was usual for things that broke the color pie to be rare. Green flyers probably would kick a damn lotta ass.

True... but we can also all agree that, today, nobody would ever seriously play this card. Hence the 1/5 ratings. To rate this card for what it was back in the day would be total nonsense and the rating system would mean nothing.

Everyone rates cards based on their knowledge of the game. This card is overcosted and has a ho-hum ability by current standards especially considering green today makes heavy use of trample and does not need for their "fatties" to fly.