x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 4.025 / 5  (59 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
123 >
Again with Lilly this is now rather playable.
He rides across the nation!!!!!
Posted By: master_biomancer (7/9/2013 5:32:35 PM)


Liliana of the Dark Realms might make this worth trying out, and the new art is absolutely sick.
Posted By: SyntheticDreamer (7/9/2013 7:51:53 PM)


Luna? I am-
Nightmare Moon!
I have but one royal duty now!
Doom Blade. *avoid fate*
And where do you think YOU'RE going!?
Doom Blade. *faith's shield*
*Cloud Cover* Mortify
Bloodcurdling Scream
Hideous Laughter
No... how could Luna do this...
*Mending Touch*
You're alright!
... Celestia?
Oh sister, I'm sorry, but you've given me no choice but to use, these.
Are those... the elements of harmony?
But that's how they looked in...
The past.
This is the night you banished her.
Doom Blade
*Stave Off*

Harmonize, Oblivion Ring
Screams of the Damned

Twilight Sparkle Phases back in.
Posted By: ZaisConsultant (3/19/2014 5:08:17 PM)


Too late for nightmare sadly, it should be uncommon now, too many rare creatures at same cmc are much better.
Posted By: Sheoldreds_Chosen (7/10/2013 7:18:10 AM)


"The horsemen are drawing nearer..."
Posted By: Sonserf369 (7/9/2013 8:56:18 PM)


Wow. A flat-out 4/5 rated card. Nice.
Posted By: ExzcellionGamma (7/24/2013 6:35:01 AM)


It's a creature that's always on curve. And that's bad. BAD.

Posted By: Swag_Crow (12/27/2013 7:46:34 AM)


This is an absolutely awesome artwork.

This is I feel a perfect card to use as reference for "How do we make cards look enough like homages to the old art styles while using the new styles to match better the more shiny new cards?" I mean honestly compare the Xth Nightmare to the Alpha Nightmare to THIS Nightmare, and it's immediately obvious that the Xth one is the worst art of the lot, just because this is so much like the Alpha art and it's a very tough call between the two.

I really, really want to see more art directions say "Look at M14 Nightmare. Do that, only for this card. Make it look New, the Old-Fashioned way." I think it can even be applied to cards that don't yet have old-fashioned artworks!

In fact I'm going to have to write into Jeremy Jarvis about this one. Who did that? Vance....Kovaks? (squinting) Yeah he's a cool man. A very cool man.

Nightmare is awesome because I think it's one of the first cards that really really scales in power with "Shock Logic"-- ie, it... (see all)
Posted By: DarthParallax (7/17/2013 8:54:01 PM)


What crappy art, it fills only half of the card, it looks like a little plastic horse, liked the old art better. Still glad to see it back though.
Posted By: Sironos (7/23/2013 6:10:24 AM)


I saw the new art for this in DOTP 2014. Once it was spoiled I was excited, but I was mostly hoping Chittering rats would get a reprint with its new art. Perhaps next time my friend. Glad to see this at least
Posted By: cotf1692 (7/12/2013 2:16:23 AM)