x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 3.641 / 5  (64 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
12345 >
Yes, this triggers every time it attacks, but how on Earth (or on Ocean) does that mean it combos with Populate?
Posted By: sonorhC (8/22/2013 9:59:55 PM)


I'd almost this rather be a 4/6 creature... 7 mana cost for only 5 toughness isn't all that hot.. Good card if you can get it to stick for a couple turns... They will be in some trouble at that point.
Posted By: Zylo- (8/23/2013 9:57:41 PM)


This is a really Great Whale.
This is a great card which is a whale.
This card is clearly much bigger in artwork and in name than Great Whale.
This card is in the same pose as his great (grandson) whale.
Posted By: ZaisConsultant (2/8/2014 10:31:37 PM)


Bonus points if you snag a Puppet Conjurer with this thing.
Posted By: PopcornBunni (3/7/2014 12:32:18 PM)



Disperse. :3

Edit: Hate me if you must, but you have to admit that would be pretty funny.

Also, I think the magnitude of this whale's size is clearly demonstrated by its ability to swallow Eldrazi like nobody's business. It's just a 5/5 because, despite its bigness, it is still otherwise not effective in combat. Gameplay-wise, the only real problem with the whale is he costs 2 mana more than he should. At 7-8 mana we get abilities that hit multiple creatures at once like Shipbreaker Kraken and Stormtide Leviathan, but this can only take out one guy at a time, and only when attacking. At 7 CMC, that's too slow. At 5 CMC, it's about right. Actually, that might even be pushing it. Maybe.
Posted By: Aelvr (3/20/2014 2:58:45 PM)



You have a good point. I think that the flavor is that the whale doesn't have any special powers; it's just really big. According to the art, the whale is probably the size of BFM's head, which IS pretty ridiculous, but I don't think that the whale is BIGGER than BFM... But yeah. It should not be a 5/5.
Posted By: OlvynChuru (4/19/2014 2:53:17 PM)


Let the Yo Mama jokes commence!
Posted By: car2n (6/1/2014 10:14:25 PM)


Gatherer works better in the Companion app!