x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 1.113 / 5  (151 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
1234 >
I don't think it's that bad, actually. I mean, there are better creatures, but it's not terrible. 2/5.
Posted By: NeoKoda (6/26/2011 2:42:20 PM)


"The world knew silence before you were born. We can restore that peace quite easily, if you give us no reason to permit your noise." - Cinder proverb.
Posted By: willpell (5/12/2011 11:19:30 PM)


Urza's Incubators and this actually seems pretty good for an elemental or warrior deck. You don't get much beefier in those tribes
Posted By: Kryptnyt (10/4/2010 3:17:50 PM)


Oh cmon, it's not THAT bad!! I mean, it's at least a 4/3 for 6 in black, and usually a 5/4! It's at least better than Bog Hoodlums
Posted By: Superllama12 (3/24/2011 8:00:08 PM)


Part of a running super-cycle of terrible black commons that cost 5B or 4BB. Basically, if you see a common black creature that costs 6 mana, it'll probably be something horrible like this thing, Bog Hoodlums, Ashenmoor Cohort, etc.
Posted By: Radagast (12/1/2011 12:26:07 PM)


"None will concede a place for us in their deck."
Posted By: PhantomDust (12/4/2011 11:24:10 AM)


Wait, what? A 6 mana vanilla 4/3 that can at its best be a vanilla 5/4? Chimney Imp at least had flying...
Posted By: True_Mumin (6/30/2009 9:06:47 AM)


Cmon, this is NOT the worst card in magic. The worst card in magic is most certainly Break Open.

Think about it this way- if you the option of just playing Ashenmoor Cohort for free with no drawbacks whatsoever, you'd do it, right? I mean, a 4/3 creature with a stupid ability is at least better than nothing.

If you had the option of playing Break Open for free though, there is NO WAY you would take that option. In 98% of games it would just do nothing. In the 2% of games in which it could actually target something, you STILL wouldn't want to play it because its obviously insane to turn a colorless, ability-less 2/2 into an Akroma, Angel of Wrath.

Posted By: Eric1618 (10/14/2010 2:25:56 AM)


If I got a penny for everytime this card was useful in a deck. I would be pennyless
Posted By: BongHippie (2/14/2010 8:32:27 PM)


Just did a search on cards with a rating of less than 0.6
There were 13
This was one of them
Posted By: psyklone (1/17/2010 7:48:47 PM)


We have updated our privacy policy. Click the link to learn more.

Gatherer works better in the Companion app!