x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 3.731 / 5  (80 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
123 >
Really cool artwork. I'm a sucker for crows.
Posted By: JWolps (12/13/2009 9:40:13 AM)


This card is ridiculous in Standard.
Posted By: coyotemoon722 (12/19/2009 7:55:39 AM)


I like this card. I love Mind Sludge. I fear Mind Twist!
Posted By: AngelxLegna (4/19/2010 2:07:09 PM)


of course mind twist is better, don't complain about this card, its just more balanced. comparing it to mind twist is like comparing time warp to time walk, tho it wasn't quite as nerfed.
Posted By: Gezus82 (10/8/2009 11:05:41 PM)


Mind Shatter: Now with smaller card text!
Posted By: Vinifera7 (7/11/2009 4:48:32 PM)


Wasn't Mind Twist banned for being to powerful? With no Mox or Lotus behind it and 1 more cost I guess its not. Discard at random is at least 50% better than opponents choice. Maybe with some green behind it for mana speed, this can be a nasty top deck but also a late game dead draw. It may just need the right deck to be devastating.
Posted By: Chromatone (7/24/2009 1:42:15 PM)


@Sucros: Will crows come out of his head too?
Posted By: auriscope (1/30/2011 10:11:05 PM)


You'd never play Mind Twist until late game anyway unless you had the appropriate mana boost, and if Mind Shatter were in your hand instead it'd still be just as debilitating. Mind Twist is the best in discard, but all things considered this is just as good in the current Standard and Extended formats.
Posted By: OmniMarconi67 (9/11/2009 4:35:25 PM)


I love this card, it's very powerful. I mind shattered somebody for their hand with two megrims out for a total of 20 life. The only shame is most decks don't have many cards in their hands when you get the mana to do good damage.
Posted By: VoidedNote (3/4/2010 8:56:11 PM)


This is a great card. Even with just five lands in play, making your opponent discard 3 at random in the midgame usually ends up being pretty painful. Most of the time when I put this in, it turns the tide in my favor immediately.
Posted By: Statix (9/18/2009 4:42:23 PM)


We have updated our privacy policy. Click the link to learn more.

Gatherer works better in the Companion app!