x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 2.351 / 5  (37 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
123 >
My opinion of this card is inversely proportional to how much of the text I had read.
Posted By: MrPink343 (7/25/2010 10:33:57 PM)


Show me changelings!

Also, it becomes less painful with Terra Eternal in play.
Posted By: McThor (8/12/2010 6:20:48 PM)


So, HERE is what you do:
1. Play Buried Alive, discarding Feral Shadow, Breathstealer and Urborg Panther.
2. Play Return of the Nightstalkers.
3. Activate Urborg Panther's ability.
4. ???
5. Profit!
Posted By: boneclub (2/3/2011 11:04:58 PM)


or you could just use, you know, nonbasic lands.
Posted By: metalevolence (12/12/2010 1:42:14 AM)


Honestly, I love it for being so bizarre and specific.

Besides - it's a sick combo with Nightstalker Engine! Man, a total of 12 mana for a vanilla 0/3 is pretty over the top, especially when you have no lands.
Posted By: Kirbster (6/25/2012 11:54:24 AM)


was destroying all swamps really required at the cost of seven mana?
i mean, Nightstalker isn't quite the most useful tribal type anyways...
whoever created the card, he or she seemingly enjoyed more creating some flavour rather than considering the usefulness^^
Posted By: Mode (2/21/2009 9:13:09 AM)


I agree that the destroy all you swamps is a bit silly, but playing Nightstalkers in tribal is too fun to worry about the particulars.
Posted By: UNBAN_SHAHRAZAD (8/31/2009 4:53:18 PM)


I could see this working okay if Nightstalker was a more prevalent type, and you had an Elsewhere Flask on the field so you could pay then turn all of your swamps into forests or something, but otherwise it's kinda... not good. Changelings could maybe use this card too, but still.
Posted By: InjuryMan (8/13/2009 9:24:19 AM)



Wait, so I spend an absurd amount of mana AND sacrifice all my Swamps to bring back all of some obscure creature type?!

If you could at least have chosen a creature type it wouldn't have been totally laughable (though it would still be grossly overcosted), and truthfully if it brought back all your creatures it would probably be acceptable given the insane cost of playing this card.

Perhaps one of the most expensive nearly-useless cards in Magic history.
Posted By: Radagast (1/16/2011 2:00:25 PM)


Posted By: LordOfTheFlies87 (5/3/2012 12:31:56 PM)