x If you're looking for a specific comment, check the other printings as well.
Player Rating:
Community Rating: 3.833 / 5  (24 votes)
The player rating is the overall rating for the card taking into account all player rating votes.

Popular Comments
Hide Comments
Only show me comments rated:
12 >
Does proliferate give me a new pair of shoes? Waiting to hear from Wizards on this one!
Posted By: jfre81 (6/2/2011 5:44:49 PM)


Mark Rosewater's tumblr, February 26, 2012:

"iamclearlyawizard asked: Silver bordered rules question, if you proliferate the shoe counters on shoe elemental, do you get a whole new pair of shoes?

Proliferate will allow you to add a shoe counter but you have to provide the shoe."

Shoe Tree, not Elemental, but the ruling is still there.
Posted By: Axelle (2/26/2012 9:10:40 PM)


oh how better it would be to be a 3 legged person.
Posted By: LeMaK (1/12/2010 11:40:58 PM)


The shoes that are used are the owner's, which is what "your: refers to. Donate changes controllers, not owners, so the shoe counters are still your shoes.
Posted By: sarroth (3/12/2011 8:48:41 PM)


Posted By: rinoh20 (5/17/2011 8:33:25 PM)


@Ryney: I don't get your logic. The card says that you can put 0, 1, or 2 counters on it, and no more. That's what "up to" means.
Posted By: Fanaticmogg (2/3/2012 10:25:15 AM)


@ snaxme. yeah, and what if you have counters on him and donate it, do you still use the previous controllers shoes? Could you win the game by preparing yourself by putting an extra pair of shoes into your backpack so that you have enough,and then lett him come into play with doubling season out, and then donate this card, so that he looses the game bacause he can'ty fulfill thhe rules?
Posted By: Ameisenber (4/11/2010 10:55:15 AM)


Stepping in to dog doo before might win you the game!
Posted By: Magasul (11/5/2009 6:09:17 AM)


...what if you, through some random way, increase the number of counters on it? Whose shoes would you use?
Posted By: Snaxme (12/12/2009 2:51:16 AM)


Well seeing as how it actually says "Up to two counters on it", I assume you can put more if you have more shoes.
Posted By: Ryney (7/17/2010 9:19:04 PM)


We have updated our privacy policy. Click the link to learn more.

Gatherer works better in the Companion app!