Strictly worse than Fact or Fiction and not worth playing, in my opinion. With the opponent choosing you WON'T get the card you want/need (unless said opponent is rather dumb), you don't get to play mind games which, let's face it, make a difference.

Another big, BIG, BIIIIIG advantage of FoF: One blue and 3. There were no real color limitations to the card. It was splashable! This one isn't. Though, with all the double-colored lands running around compared to the Invasion block, it MIGHT not be such a big deal.

Anywho. No doubt, switching the splitting and choosing roles around ruined the card. Well, no not RUINED, that's a little extreme, but it's not without valid substitutes. I mean, Read the Bones let's you dig up to four cards deep for the one card you need a turn before this one.