| Piety | Mark Poole | White | C | Fourth Edition |
| Piety | Mark Poole | White | C | Arabian Nights |
| Piety | Mark Poole | White | C | Arabian Nights |
| 49 | Piety Charm | David Martin | White | C | Onslaught |
| 148 | Piggy Bank | Steve Ellis | Red | U | Duskmourn: House of Horror |
| 111 | Pigment Storm | Bayard Wu | Red | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| Pikemen | Dan Frazier | White | C | Fifth Edition |
| Pikemen | Dennis Detwiller | White | C | Fourth Edition |
| Pikemen | Denise Detwiler | White | C | The Dark |
| 122 | Pile On | Javier Charro | Black | R | March of the Machine |
| 134 | Pile On | Javier Charro | Black | R | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander |
| 361 | Pile On | Javier Charro | Black | R | March of the Machine |
| 25 | Pileated Provisioner | Eelis Kyttanen | White | C | Bloomburrow |
| 102 | Pilfer | Pauline Voss | Black | U | Dominaria United |
| 181 | Pilfer | Pauline Voss | Black | C | Magic: The Gathering Foundations |
| 90 | Pilfered Plans | Michael C. Hayes | Blue/Black | C | Dragon's Maze |
| 178 | Pilfered Plans | Michael C. Hayes | Blue/Black | C | Modern Masters 2017 Edition |
| 71 | Pilfering Hawk | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Kaldheim |
| 336 | Pilfering Hawk | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 81 | Pilfering Imp | Igor Kieryluk | Black | U | Guilds of Ravnica |
| 40 | Pilgrim of Justice | Orizio Daniele | White | C | Odyssey |
| 16 | Pilgrim of the Ages | Jihun | White | C | Game Night: Free-For-All |
| 22 | Pilgrim of the Ages | Jihun | White | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 225 | Pilgrim of the Ages | Jihun | White | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 162 | Pilgrim of the Fires | Izzy | | U | Fate Reforged |
| 41 | Pilgrim of Virtue | Massimilano Frezzato | White | C | Odyssey |
| 47 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Duel Decks: Venser vs. Koth |
| 55 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | U | Game Night |
| 128 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Worldwake |
| 210 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander Anthology 2018 |
| 214 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander 2018 |
| 224 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander Anthology |
| 226 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | U | Battle for Zendikar |
| 229 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Eternal Masters |
| 253 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander 2013 Edition |
| 257 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander 2021 |
| 262 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander 2014 |
| 263 | Pilgrim's Eye | Sean Murray | | C | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate |
| 332 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander Legends |
| 333 | Pilgrim's Eye | Sean Murray | | C | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 402 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Commander Masters |
| 791 | Pilgrim's Eye | Dan Scott | | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 258 | Pili-Pala | Ron Spencer | | C | Shadowmoor |
| Pillage | Richard Kane Ferguson | Red | U | Alliances |
| 24 | Pillage | Bradley Williams | Red | U | Premium Deck Series: Fire and Lightning |
| 139 | Pillage | Jesper Ejsing | Red | U | Modern Horizons |
| 144 | Pillage | Jesper Ejsing | Red | C | Masters 25 |
| 146 | Pillage | Richard Kane Ferguson | Red | U | Masters Edition II |
| 198 | Pillage | Richard Kane Ferguson | Red | U | Classic Sixth Edition |
| 207 | Pillage | Bradley Williams | Red | U | Seventh Edition |
| 224 | Pillage the Bog | Forrest Imel | Black/Green | R | Outlaws of Thunder Junction |
| 359 | Pillage the Bog | Forrest Imel | Black/Green | R | Outlaws of Thunder Junction |
| Pillaging Horde | Kev Walker | Red | R | Portal |
| 180 | Pillaging Horde | Kev Walker | Red | U | Vintage Masters |
| 141 | Pillar of Flame | Karl Kopinski | Red | C | Iconic Masters |
| 149 | Pillar of Flame | Karl Kopinski | Red | C | Avacyn Restored |
| 355 | Pillar of Flame | Dave Kendall | Red | C | Jumpstart |
| 579 | Pillar of Flame | Dave Kendall | Red | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 24 | Pillar of Light | Erica Yang | White | C | Magic 2015 Core Set |
| 241 | Pillar of Origins | Dimitar | | U | Ixalan |
| 970 | Pillar of Origins | Dimitar Marinski | | U | Commander Masters |
| 176 | Pillar of the Paruns | Dany Orizio | | R | Dissension |
| 328 | Pillar of the Paruns | Dany Orizio | | R | Double Masters 2022 |
| 372 | Pillar of the Paruns | Randy Gallegos | | M | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 572 | Pillar of the Paruns | Dany Orizio | | R | Double Masters 2022 |
| 160 | Pillar of War | Aleksi Briclot | | U | Born of the Gods |
| Pillar Tombs of Aku | Terese Nielsen | Black | R | Visions |
| 23 | Pillardrop Rescuer | Jason A. Engle | White | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 226 | Pillardrop Rescuer | Jason A. Engle | White | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 112 | Pillardrop Warden | Antonio José Manzanedo | Red | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 25 | Pillarfield Ox | Andrew Robinson | White | C | Magic 2013 |
| 28 | Pillarfield Ox | Andrew Robinson | White | C | Magic 2014 Core Set |
| 31 | Pillarfield Ox | Andrew Robinson | White | C | Zendikar |
| 76 | Pillarfield Ox | Andrew Robinson | White | C | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 263 | Pillarverge Pathway | Piotr Dura | | R | Zendikar Rising |
| 288 | Pillarverge Pathway | Noah Bradley | | R | Zendikar Rising |
| 44 | Pillory of the Sleepless | Marc Simonetti | White/Black | U | Guild Kit: Orzhov |
| 125 | Pillory of the Sleepless | Mark Romanoski | White/Black | C | Guildpact |
| 183 | Pillory of the Sleepless | Marc Simonetti | White/Black | U | Modern Masters 2015 Edition |
| 213 | Pillory of the Sleepless | Marc Simonetti | White/Black | U | Masters 25 |
| 23 | Pin Collection | Ben Maier | White | U | Unfinity |
| 45 | Pin to the Earth | Johann Bodin | Blue | C | Journey into Nyx |
| 201 | Pincer Spider | Dan Frazier | Green | C | Invasion |
| Pincher Beetles | Stephen Daniele | Green | C | Battle Royale Box Set |
| Pincher Beetles | Stephen Daniele | Green | C | Tempest |
| 285 | Pincher Beetles | Stephen Daniele | Green | C | Tenth Edition |
| 552 | Pinchy McStingbutt (playtest) | Drew Moss | Black | R | Mystery Booster 2: Convention Edition |
| Pine Barrens | Rebecca Guay | | R | Tempest |
| 240 | Pine Barrens | Rebecca Guay | | U | Tempest Remastered |
| 307 | Pine Barrens | Rebecca Guay | | U | Vintage Masters |
| 143 | Pine Walker | Dave Kendall | Green | U | Khans of Tarkir |
| 281 | Pinecrest Ridge | John Avon | | U | Champions of Kamigawa |
| 195 | Pinion Feast | Ryan Barger | Green | C | Dragons of Tarkir |
| 136 | Pink Horror | Games Workshop | Blue/Red | R | Warhammer 40,000 Commander |
| 246 | Pinnacle Monk | Jason A. Engle | Red | U | Modern Horizons 3 |
| 105 | Pinnacle of Rage | Noah Bradley | Red | U | Born of the Gods |
| 221 | Pinpoint Avalanche | Darrell Riche | Red | C | Onslaught |
| 34 | Pious Evangel | Kev Walker | White | U | Shadows over Innistrad |
| 26 | Pious Interdiction | Lake Hurwitz | White | C | Ixalan |
| 38 | Pious Kitsune | Anthony S. Waters | White | C | Champions of Kamigawa |
| 34 | Pious Warrior | Jeff Miracola | White | C | Mercadian Masques |
| 32 | Pious Wayfarer | Mark Zug | White | C | Theros Beyond Death |
| 227 | Pious Wayfarer | Mark Zug | White | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 140 | Pip-Boy 3000 | Mirko Failoni | | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 435 | Pip-Boy 3000 | Mirko Failoni | | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 100 | Piper of the Swarm | Irina Nordsol | Black | R | Throne of Eldraine |
| 106 | Piper of the Swarm | Irina Nordsol | Black | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 392 | Piper of the Swarm | Jesper Ejsing | Black | R | Throne of Eldraine |
| 36 | Piper Wright, Publick Reporter | Rafater | Blue | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 379 | Piper Wright, Publick Reporter | Rafater | Blue | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 261 | Piper's Melody | Greg & Tim Hildebrandt | Green | U | Odyssey |
| 68 | Pippa, Duchess of Dice | Simon Dominic | Green | R | Unsanctioned |
| 218 | Pippin, Guard of the Citadel | Bartłomiej Gaweł | White/Blue | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 326 | Pippin, Guard of the Citadel | Anato Finnstark | White/Blue | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 438 | Pippin, Guard of the Citadel | Martina Fačková | White/Blue | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 669 | Pippin, Guard of the Citadel | Bartłomiej Gaweł | White/Blue | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 65 | Pippin, Warden of Isengard | Viko Menezes | Black/Green | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 146 | Pippin, Warden of Isengard | Viko Menezes | Black/Green | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 472 | Pippin, Warden of Isengard | Viko Menezes | Black/Green | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 182 | Pippin's Bravery | John Tedrick | Green | C | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 414 | Pippin's Bravery | David Rapoza | Green | C | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 633 | Pippin's Bravery | John Tedrick | Green | C | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth |
| 11 | Pir, Imaginative Rascal | Zoltan Boros | Green | R | Battlebond |
| Piracy | Brad Williams | Blue | R | Portal Second Age |
| 45 | Piracy | Bradley Williams | Blue | R | Starter 1999 |
| 58 | Piracy Charm | John Avon | Blue | C | Planar Chaos |
| 78 | Piracy Charm | John Avon | Blue | C | Time Spiral Remastered |
| 70 | Piranha Fly | Kekai Kotaki | Blue | C | Duskmourn: House of Horror |
| 222 | Piranha Marsh | Nic Klein | | C | Zendikar |
| 818 | Piranha Marsh | Nic Klein | | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 70 | Pirate Hat | Domenico Cava | Blue | C | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Fifth Edition |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Fourth Edition |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Revised Edition |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Unlimited Edition |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Limited Edition Beta |
| Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | R | Limited Edition Alpha |
| 28 | Pirate Ship | Tom Wänerstrand | Blue | S | Time Spiral "Timeshifted" |
| 16 | Pirated Copy | Daarken | Blue | M | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 242 | Pirate's Cutlass | John Stanko | | C | Ixalan |
| 333 | Pirate's Cutlass | John Stanko | | C | Commander Legends |
| 477 | Pirate's Cutlass | John Stanko | | C | Jumpstart |
| 563 | Pirate's Cutlass | John Stanko | | C | Magic: The Gathering Foundations |
| 109 | Pirate's Pillage | Wayne Reynolds | Red | U | Rivals of Ixalan |
| 120 | Pirate's Pillage | Wayne Reynolds | Red | C | Double Masters 2022 |
| 68 | Pirate's Prize | Deruchenko Alexander | Blue | C | Ixalan |
| 73 | Pir's Whim | Jakub Kasper | Green | R | Battlebond |
| 207 | Piru, the Volatile | Greg Staples | White/Black/Red | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 422 | Piru, the Volatile | Greg Staples | White/Black/Red | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 466 | Piru, the Volatile | Greg Staples | White/Black/Red | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 124 | Piston Sledge | Pete Venters | | U | Mirrodin Besieged |
| 217 | Piston-Fist Cyclops | Wayne Reynolds | Blue/Red | C | Guilds of Ravnica |
| 86 | Pistus Strike | Jaime Jones | Green | C | Mirrodin Besieged |
| 93 | Pit Fight | Matt Stewart | Red/Green | C | Guild Kit: Gruul |
| 202 | Pit Fight | Matt Stewart | Red/Green | C | Ravnica Clue Edition |
| 223 | Pit Fight | Matt Stewart | Red/Green | C | Gatecrash |
| Pit Imp | Phil Foglio | Black | C | Tempest |
| 81 | Pit Keeper | Anthony S. Waters | Black | C | Modern Masters 2017 Edition |
| 123 | Pit Keeper | Anthony S. Waters | Black | C | Time Spiral |
| 130 | Pit Keeper | Anthony S. Waters | Black | C | Time Spiral Remastered |
| 455 | Pit Keeper | Anthony S. Waters | Black | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 278 | Pit of Offerings | Martin de Diego Sádaba | | U | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 72 | Pit Raptor | Thomas Gianni | Black | U | Prophecy |
| Pit Scorpion | Ian Miller | Black | C | Fifth Edition |
| Pit Scorpion | Scott Kirschner | Black | C | Fourth Edition |
| Pit Scorpion | Scott Kirschner | Black | C | Legends |
| 70 | Pit Spawn | Thomas M. Baxa | Black | R | Exodus |
| Pit Trap | Anson Maddocks | | U | Ice Age |
| 307 | Pit Trap | Brian Snoddy | | U | Urza's Saga |
| 313 | Pit Trap | Nelson DeCastro | | U | Seventh Edition |
| 149 | Pitchburn Devils | Johann Bodin | Red | C | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 149 | Pitchburn Devils | Johann Bodin | Red | C | Magic 2014 Core Set |
| 156 | Pitchburn Devils | Johann Bodin | Red | C | Core Set 2021 |
| 156 | Pitchburn Devils | Johann Bodin | Red | C | Innistrad |
| 110 | Pitchstone Wall | David Martin | Red | U | Torment |
| 18 | Pitfall Trap | Franz Vohwinkel | White | C | Modern Masters 2017 Edition |
| 32 | Pitfall Trap | Franz Vohwinkel | White | U | Zendikar |
| 69 | Pith Driller | Nils Hamm | Black | C | New Phyrexia |
| 44 | Pithing Needle | Joshua Howard | | R | Secret Lair Drop |
| 44 | Pithing Needle | Joseph Meehan | | S | Masterpiece Series: Kaladesh Inventions |
| 158 | Pithing Needle | Pete Venters | | R | Saviors of Kamigawa |
| 217 | Pithing Needle | Pete Venters | | R | Magic 2010 |
| 231 | Pithing Needle | Anthony Palumbo | | R | Return to Ravnica |
| 257 | Pithing Needle | Ovidio Cartagena | | R | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 312 | Pithing Needle | Anthony Palumbo | | R | Double Masters 2022 |
| 338 | Pithing Needle | Pete Venters | | R | Tenth Edition |
| 378 | Pithing Needle | Ovidio Cartagena | | R | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 397 | Pithing Needle | Ron Spencer | | R | Double Masters 2022 |
| 463 | Pithing Needle | Anthony Palumbo | | R | Ravnica Remastered |
| 564 | Pithing Needle | Anthony Palumbo | | R | Double Masters 2022 |
| 108 | Pithing Spyglass (playtest) | Melissa DeTora | | C | Mystery Booster |
| 98 | Pitiless Carnage | Richard Kane Ferguson | Black | R | Outlaws of Thunder Junction |
| 326 | Pitiless Carnage | Richard Kane Ferguson | Black | R | Outlaws of Thunder Junction |
| 203 | Pitiless Gorgon | Alex Konstad | Black/Green | C | Ravnica Clue Edition |
| 218 | Pitiless Gorgon | Alex Konstad | Black/Green | C | Guilds of Ravnica |
| 112 | Pitiless Horde | Viktor Titov | Black | R | Dragons of Tarkir |
| 5 | Pitiless Plunderer | Johan Grenier | Black | U | Special Guests |
| 46 | Pitiless Plunderer | David Palumbo | Black | U | Mystery Booster 2: Convention Edition |
| 81 | Pitiless Plunderer | David Palumbo | Black | U | Rivals of Ixalan |
| 187 | Pitiless Plunderer | Nicholas Gregory | Black | U | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 208 | Pitiless Plunderer | David Palumbo | Black | U | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander |
| 194 | Pitiless Pontiff | Yongjae Choi | White/Black | U | Ravnica Allegiance |
| 103 | Pitiless Vizier | Volkan Baga | Black | C | Amonkhet |
| 119 | Pitiless Vizier | Volkan Baga | Black | C | Amonkhet Remastered |
| 84 | Pixie Dust | Edgar Sánchez Hidalgo | Blue | U | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 66 | Pixie Guide | Fariba Khamseh | Blue | C | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms |
| 309 | Pixie Guide | Justine Mara Andersen | Blue | C | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms |
| 61 | Pixie Illusionist | Anastasia Ovchinnikova | Blue | C | Dominaria United |
| Pixie Queen | Quinton Hoover | Green | R | Legends |
| 199 | Placid Rottentail | Filip Burburan | Green | C | March of the Machine |
| 44 | Plagiarize | Ben Thompson | Blue | R | Torment |
| 89 | Plagiarize | Jeremy Jarvis | Blue | R | Ninth Edition |
| 97 | Plagiarize | Jeremy Jarvis | Blue | R | Tenth Edition |
| 64 | Plague Beetle | Tom Fleming | Black | C | Urza's Legacy |
| 154 | Plague Beetle | Tom Fleming | Black | C | Ninth Edition |
| 154 | Plague Beetle | Matt Cavotta | Black | C | Eighth Edition |
| 155 | Plague Beetle | Matt Cavotta | Black | C | Seventh Edition |
| 168 | Plague Beetle | Tom Fleming | Black | C | Tenth Edition |