| 23 | Idle Thoughts | Steven Belledin | Blue | U | Eventide |
| 23 | Idol of Endurance | Kim Sokol | White | R | Core Set 2021 |
| 342 | Idol of Endurance | Kim Sokol | White | R | Core Set 2021 |
| 210 | Idol of False Gods | Nicholas Gregory | | U | Modern Horizons 3 |
| 55 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Commander 2019 |
| 134 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander |
| 144 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | The Brothers' War Commander |
| 229 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander |
| 246 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Commander 2021 |
| 258 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander |
| 277 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 297 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | U | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 368 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Streets of New Capenna Commander |
| 392 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Commander Masters |
| 607 | Idol of Oblivion | Piotr Dura | | R | Commander Masters |
| 155 | Idol of the Deep King | Matteo Bassini | Red | C | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 17 | Idolized | Kim Sokol | White | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 327 | Idolized | Tim Brumley | White | R | Magic The Gathering—Fallout |
| 135 | Idris, Soul of the TARDIS | Manuel Castañón | Blue/Red | R | Doctor Who Commander |
| 419 | Idris, Soul of the TARDIS | Manuel Castañón | Blue/Red | R | Doctor Who Commander |
| 249 | Idyllic Beachfront | Robin Olausson | | L | Dominaria United |
| 246 | Idyllic Grange | Howard Lyon | | C | Throne of Eldraine |
| 12 | Idyllic Tutor | Howard Lyon | White | R | Morningtide |
| 24 | Idyllic Tutor | Jaime Jones | White | R | Theros Beyond Death |
| Ifh-Bíff Efreet | Jesper Myrfors | Green | R | Arabian Nights |
| 123 | Ifh-Bíff Efreet | Jesper Myrfors | Green | R | Masters Edition |
| 179 | Ifnir Deadlands | Jonas De Ro | | U | Hour of Devastation |
| 302 | Ifnir Deadlands | Jonas De Ro | | U | Amonkhet Remastered |
| 153 | Igneous Cur | Igor Kieryluk | Red | C | Core Set 2021 |
| 133 | Igneous Elemental | Anastasia Ovchinnikova | Red | C | Modern Horizons |
| Igneous Golem | Adam Rex | | U | Mirage |
| 107 | Igneous Inspiration | PINDURSKI | Red | U | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 40 | Igneous Pouncer | Chippy | Black/Red | C | Alara Reborn |
| 57 | Igneous Pouncer | Chippy | Black/Red | C | Duel Decks: Ajani vs. Nicol Bolas |
| 66 | Ignite Disorder | Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai | Red | U | Conflux |
| 141 | Ignite Disorder | Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai | Red | U | Magic 2010 |
| 164 | Ignite Memories | Justin Sweet | Red | U | Time Spiral |
| 18 | Ignite the Beacon | Slawomir Maniak | White | R | War of the Spark |
| 27 | Ignite the Future | Alex Konstad | Red | R | Commander 2019 |
| 129 | Ignite the Future | Alex Konstad | Red | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 555 | Ignite the Future | Alex Konstad | Red | R | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 797 | Ignite the Future | Alex Konstad | Red | R | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 34 | Ignition Team | Karl Kopinski | Red | R | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 166 | Ignoble Hierarch | Mark Zug | Green | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 234 | Ignoble Hierarch | Mark Zug | Green | R | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 355 | Ignoble Hierarch | Mark Zug | Green | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 414 | Ignoble Hierarch | Mark Zug | Green | R | Modern Horizons 2 |
| 22 | Ignoble Soldier | Mark Romanoski | White | U | Mercadian Masques |
| 64 | Ignorant Bliss | Shishizaru | Red | U | Dissension |
| Ihsan's Shade | Christopher Rush | Black | U | Homelands |
| 94 | Ihsan's Shade | Daarken | Black | U | Masters 25 |
| 95 | Ihsan's Shade | Christopher Rush | Black | R | Masters Edition II |
| 104 | Iizuka the Ruthless | Darrell Riche | Red | R | Saviors of Kamigawa |
| 27 | Ikiral Outrider | Kekai Kotaki | White | C | Rise of the Eldrazi |
| 11 | Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper | Josu Hernaiz | Black/Green | M | Commander Anthology 2018 |
| 32 | Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper | Josu Hernaiz | Black/Green | M | Commander 2016 |
| 519 | Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper | Josu Hernaiz | Black/Green | M | Commander Legends |
| 113 | Ilharg, the Raze-Boar | Filip Burburan | Red | M | Ravnica Remastered |
| 133 | Ilharg, the Raze-Boar | Filip Burburan | Red | M | War of the Spark |
| 334 | Ilharg, the Raze-Boar | Filip Burburan | Red | M | Ravnica Remastered |
| 429 | Ilharg, the Raze-Boar | Moopic | Red | M | Ravnica Remastered |
| 114 | Ill-Gotten Gains | Greg Staples | Black | R | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 138 | Ill-Gotten Gains | Greg Staples | Black | R | Urza's Saga |
| 77 | Ill-Gotten Inheritance | Winona Nelson | Black | C | Ravnica Remastered |
| 77 | Ill-Gotten Inheritance | Winona Nelson | Black | C | Ravnica Allegiance |
| 427 | Ill-Gotten Inheritance | Winona Nelson | Black | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| Illicit Auction | Scott Kirschner | Red | R | Mirage |
| 190 | Illicit Auction | Scott Kirschner | Red | R | Classic Sixth Edition |
| 88 | Illicit Masquerade | Valera Lutfullina | Black | R | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| 401 | Illicit Masquerade | Valera Lutfullina | Black | R | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| 83 | Illicit Shipment | Josu Hernaiz | Black | U | Streets of New Capenna |
| 76 | Illithid Harvester | David Astruga | Blue | R | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 122 | Illithid Harvester | David Astruga | Blue | R | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate |
| 564 | Illithid Harvester | David Astruga | Blue | R | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 69 | Illness in the Ranks | Nils Hamm | Black | U | Gatecrash |
| 125 | Ill-Tempered Cyclops | Peter Mohrbacher | Red | C | Theros |
| 166 | Ill-Tempered Cyclops | Peter Mohrbacher | Red | C | Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
| 162 | Ill-Tempered Loner | Grzegorz Rutkowski | Red | R | Innistrad: Crimson Vow |
| 378 | Ill-Tempered Loner | Grzegorz Rutkowski | Red | R | Innistrad: Crimson Vow |
| 207 | Ill-Timed Explosion | Aaron J. Riley | Blue/Red | R | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| 416 | Ill-Timed Explosion | Aaron J. Riley | Blue/Red | R | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| 63 | Illuminate | Christopher Moeller | Red | U | Apocalypse |
| 108 | Illuminate History | Jokubas Uogintas | Red | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 312 | Illuminate History | Jokubas Uogintas | Red | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 254 | Illuminated Folio | Jim Pavelec | | U | Shadowmoor |
| 34 | Illuminated Wings | Jim Nelson | Blue | C | Urza's Destiny |
| Illumination | David O'Connor | White | U | Mirage |
| 17 | Illuminator Virtuoso | John Stanko | White | U | Streets of New Capenna |
| 37 | Illuminor Szeras | Darren Tan | Black | R | Warhammer 40,000 Commander |
| 154 | Illuna, Apex of Wishes | Chris Rahn | Blue/Red/Green | M | Dominaria United Commander |
| 190 | Illuna, Apex of Wishes | Chris Rahn | Blue/Red/Green | M | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 379 | Illuna, Apex of Wishes | Nicholas Gregory | Blue/Red/Green | M | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 129 | Illusion | David Martin | Blue | U | Apocalypse |
| 129 | Illusion | John Avon | Blue | U | Apocalypse |
| 213 | Illusion | John Avon & David Martin | Blue | U | Dominaria Remastered |
| 31 | Illusion of Choice | John Severin Brassell | Blue | U | Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
| 59 | Illusionary Armor | Mathias Kollros | Blue | U | Magic 2014 Core Set |
| Illusionary Forces | Justin Hampton | Blue | C | Ice Age |
| 38 | Illusionary Forces | Justin Hampton | Blue | U | Masters Edition |
| 32 | Illusionary Informant | Tomasz Jedruszek | Blue | C | Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
| Illusionary Mask | Amy Weber | | R | Unlimited Edition |
| Illusionary Mask | Amy Weber | | R | Limited Edition Beta |
| Illusionary Mask | Amy Weber | | R | Limited Edition Alpha |
| 197 | Illusionary Mask | Amy Weber | | R | Masters Edition III |
| Illusionary Presence | Kaja Foglio | Blue | R | Ice Age |
| 57 | Illusionary Servant | Dave Kendall | Blue | C | Magic 2010 |
| Illusionary Terrain | Rob Alexander | Blue | U | Ice Age |
| Illusionary Wall | Mark Poole | Blue | C | Ice Age |
| 39 | Illusionary Wall | Mark Poole | Blue | C | Masters Edition |
| 231 | Illusionist's Bracers | Svetlin Velinov | | R | Gatecrash |
| 260 | Illusionist's Bracers | Svetlin Velinov | | R | Ravnica Remastered |
| 392 | Illusionist's Bracers | Svetlin Velinov | | R | Ravnica Remastered |
| 47 | Illusionist's Gambit | Zoltan Boros | Blue | R | Commander 2013 Edition |
| 97 | Illusionist's Gambit | Zoltan Boros | Blue | R | Wilds of Eldraine Commander |
| 166 | Illusionist's Gambit | Zoltan Boros | Blue | R | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 36 | Illusionist's Stratagem | Svetlin Velinov | Blue | U | Aether Revolt |
| 53 | Illusionist's Stratagem | Svetlin Velinov | Blue | U | Kaladesh Remastered |
| Illusions of Grandeur | Quinton Hoover | Blue | R | Ice Age |
| 40 | Illusions of Grandeur | Quinton Hoover | Blue | R | Masters Edition |
| 12 | Illusory Ambusher | Steve Argyle | Blue | U | Commander 2015 |
| 29 | Illusory Ambusher | Steve Argyle | Blue | U | Game Night: Free-For-All |
| 58 | Illusory Ambusher | Steve Argyle | Blue | U | Iconic Masters |
| 113 | Illusory Ambusher | Steve Argyle | Blue | U | Ikoria Commander |
| 167 | Illusory Ambusher | Steve Argyle | Blue | U | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 19 | Illusory Angel | Allen Williams | Blue | U | Planechase Anthology |
| 19 | Illusory Angel | Allen Williams | Blue | U | Planechase 2012 Edition |
| 59 | Illusory Angel | Allen Williams | Blue | U | Iconic Masters |
| 59 | Illusory Angel | Allen Williams | Blue | U | Magic 2015 Core Set |
| 21 | Illusory Demon | Nils Hamm | Blue/Black | U | Alara Reborn |
| 59 | Illusory Gains | Kev Walker | Blue | R | Dragons of Tarkir |
| 58 | Illusory Wrappings | Deruchenko Alexander | Blue | C | Amonkhet |
| 109 | Illustrious Historian | Brian Valeza | Red | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 9 | Illustrious Wanderglyph | Erikas Perl | White | R | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander |
| 21 | Illustrious Wanderglyph | Erikas Perl | White | R | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander |
| 98 | Ilysian Caryatid | Winona Nelson | Green | C | Arena Base Set |
| 174 | Ilysian Caryatid | Winona Nelson | Green | C | Theros Beyond Death |
| 297 | Ilysian Caryatid | Winona Nelson | Green | C | Commander Masters |
| 676 | Ilysian Caryatid | Winona Nelson | Green | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 5 | I'm Rubber, You're Glue | Claymore J. Flapdoodle | White | R | Unglued |
| 87 | Imagecrafter | Terese Nielsen | Blue | C | Onslaught |
| 7 | Imaginary Friends (playtest) | Daniel Holt | White | C | Mystery Booster |
| 81 | Imaginary Pet | Heather Hudson | Blue | R | Urza's Saga |
| 82 | Imaginary Pet | Christopher Rush | Blue | R | Ninth Edition |
| 37 | Imaginary Threats | Magali Villeneuve | Blue | U | Hour of Devastation |
| 5 | Imaryll, Elfhame Elite | Ryan Pancoast | Green | M | Game Night: Free-For-All |
| 152 | Imbraham, Dean of Theory | Ryan Pancoast | Blue | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 326 | Imbraham, Dean of Theory | Ryan Pancoast | Blue | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 255 | Imi Statue | Todd Lockwood | | R | Champions of Kamigawa |
| 98 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Game Night: Free-For-All |
| 117 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Commander Anthology |
| 201 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Commander 2014 |
| 219 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Lorwyn |
| 234 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Commander Legends |
| 679 | Immaculate Magistrate | Jim Nelson | Green | R | Commander Legends |
| 564 | Immersturm Battlefield (playtest) | Thomas Ricci | Red | R | Mystery Booster 2: Convention Edition |
| 214 | Immersturm Predator | Nicholas Gregory | Black/Red | R | Kaldheim |
| 367 | Immersturm Predator | Nicholas Gregory | Black/Red | R | Kaldheim |
| 660 | Immersturm Predator | Nicholas Gregory | Black/Red | R | Magic: The Gathering Foundations |
| 141 | Immersturm Raider | Grzegorz Rutkowski | Red | C | Kaldheim |
| 556 | Immersturm Raider | Grzegorz Rutkowski | Red | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 263 | Immersturm Skullcairn | Cliff Childs | | U | Kaldheim |
| 65 | Immerwolf | Cristi Balanescu | Red/Green | U | Shadows of the Past |
| 141 | Immerwolf | Terese Nielsen | Red/Green | U | Dark Ascension |
| 98 | Imminent Doom | Daniel Ljunggren | Red | R | Hour of Devastation |
| 161 | Imminent Doom | Daniel Ljunggren | Red | R | Amonkhet Remastered |
| 97 | Immobilizer Eldrazi | Svetlin Velinov | Red | U | Oath of the Gatewatch |
| 87 | Immobilizing Ink | Darrell Riche | Blue | C | Odyssey |
| 20 | Immolating Glare | Daarken | White | U | Oath of the Gatewatch |
| 20 | Immolating Gyre | Campbell White | Red | M | Jumpstart |
| 139 | Immolating Souleater | Austin Hsu | | C | New Phyrexia |
| Immolation | Scott Kirschner | Red | C | Fourth Edition |
| Immolation | Scott Kirschner | Red | C | Legends |
| 103 | Immolation | Scott Kirschner | Red | C | Masters Edition III |
| 144 | Immolation | Olena Richards | Red | C | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 106 | Immolation Shaman | Svetlin Velinov | Red | R | Ravnica Allegiance |
| 79 | Immortal Coil | Dan Scott | Black | R | Shards of Alara |
| 10 | Immortal Obligation | Nino Vecia | White | R | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander |
| 321 | Immortal Obligation | Nino Vecia | White | R | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander |
| 4 | Immortal Phoenix | Daarken | Red | R | Gift Pack |
| 75 | Immortal Phoenix | Daarken | Red | R | Arena Base Set |
| 332 | Immortal Phoenix | Daarken | Red | R | Core Set 2020 |
| 220 | Immortal Servitude | Seb McKinnon | White/Black | R | Gatecrash |
| 7 | Immovable Rod | Jakub Kasper | White | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 276 | Immovable Rod | Jakub Kasper | White | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 137 | Imodane, the Pyrohammer | Chris Rahn | Red | R | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 348 | Imodane, the Pyrohammer | Chris Rahn | Red | R | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 229 | Imodane's Recruiter | Nestor Ossandon Leal | Red | U | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 77 | Imoen, Mystic Trickster | Alix Branwyn | Blue | U | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 385 | Imoen, Mystic Trickster | Pedro Potier | Blue | U | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |