| 38 | Plated Seastrider | Izzy | Blue | C | Scars of Mirrodin |
| 103 | Plated Seastrider | Izzy | Blue | C | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 12 | Plated Slagwurm | Justin Sweet | Green | R | Duel Decks Anthology, Garruk vs. Liliana |
| 12 | Plated Slagwurm | Justin Sweet | Green | R | Duel Decks: Garruk vs. Liliana |
| 127 | Plated Slagwurm | Justin Sweet | Green | R | Mirrodin |
| 19 | Plated Sliver | Greg Staples | White | C | Legions |
| Plated Spider | Ron Spencer | Green | C | Beatdown Box Set |
| 116 | Plated Spider | Ron Spencer | Green | C | Urza's Destiny |
| Plated Wurm | Daniel Gelon | Green | C | Portal Second Age |
| 13 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | M | From the Vault: Angels |
| 18 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | R | Historic Anthology 2 |
| 41 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | M | The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts |
| 46 | Platinum Angel | Victor Adame Minguez | | S | Masterpiece Series: Kaladesh Inventions |
| 104 | Platinum Angel | Ovidio Cartagena | | M | The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts |
| 212 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | M | Magic 2011 |
| 214 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | M | Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
| 218 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | M | Magic 2010 |
| 228 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | R | Mirrodin |
| 339 | Platinum Angel | Brom | | R | Tenth Edition |
| 30 | Platinum Emperion | Igor Kieryluk | | S | Ultimate Box Toppers |
| 193 | Platinum Emperion | Chris Rahn | | M | Scars of Mirrodin |
| 233 | Platinum Emperion | Igor Kieryluk | | M | Ultimate Masters |
| 36 | Platoon Dispenser | Leon Tukker | | M | The Brothers' War |
| 310 | Platoon Dispenser | Leon Tukker | | M | The Brothers' War |
| 122 | Plaxcaster Frogling | Greg Staples | Blue/Green | U | Guild Kit: Simic |
| 123 | Plaxcaster Frogling | Greg Staples | Blue/Green | U | Dissension |
| 184 | Plaxcaster Frogling | Greg Staples | Blue/Green | U | Modern Masters 2015 Edition |
| 226 | Plaxcaster Frogling | Greg Staples | Blue/Green | U | Commander 2021 |
| 29 | Plaxmanta | Alan Pollack | Blue | U | Dissension |
| 100 | Plaxmanta | Alan Pollack | Blue | U | Commander 2015 |
| 29 | Play of the Game | Jung Park | White | R | Battlebond |
| 154 | Play with Fire | Svetlin Velinov | Red | U | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 390 | Play with Fire | Svetlin Velinov | Red | U | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 30 | Playable Delusionary Hydra | Larissa Hasenheit, Mina Jeon, Daria Sergeyeva, Sam Burley | | C | Unfinity |
| 145 | Playful Shove | Zoltan Boros | Red | U | Bloomburrow |
| 254 | Plaza of Harmony | Jedd Chevrier | | R | Ravnica Allegiance |
| 252 | Plaza of Heroes | Gabor Szikszai | | R | Dominaria United |
| 421 | Plaza of Heroes | Gabor Szikszai | | R | Dominaria United |
| 24 | Plea for Guidance | Terese Nielsen | White | R | Born of the Gods |
| 24 | Plea for Power | John Severin Brassell | Blue | R | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 33 | Plea for Power | John Severin Brassell | Blue | R | Game Night: Free-For-All |
| 87 | Plea for Power | John Severin Brassell | Blue | R | Vintage Masters |
| 195 | Plea for Power | Josh Hass | Blue | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 24 | Pledge of Loyalty | Franz Vohwinkel | White | U | Invasion |
| 210 | Pledge of Unity | Chris Rallis | White/Green | U | War of the Spark |
| 152 | Plot Armor | Gaboleps | Green | C | Unfinity (Acorn) |
| 20 | Plover Knights | Quinton Hoover | White | C | Duel Decks: Knights vs. Dragons |
| 35 | Plover Knights | Quinton Hoover | White | C | Lorwyn |
| 22 | Plow Through Reito | Ron Spencer | White | C | Saviors of Kamigawa |
| 117 | Plow Under | Edward P. Beard, Jr. | Green | R | Urza's Destiny |
| 272 | Plow Under | Rob Alexander | Green | R | Eighth Edition |
| 81 | Plumb the Forbidden | Andrey Kuzinskiy | Black | U | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 188 | Plumb the Forbidden | Andrey Kuzinskiy | Black | U | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 65 | Plumecreed Escort | Manuel Castañón | Blue | U | Bloomburrow |
| 228 | Plumecreed Mentor | Henry Peters | White/Blue | U | Bloomburrow |
| 124 | Plumes of Peace | Justin Sweet | White/Blue | C | Dissension |
| 145 | Plumeveil | Nils Hamm | White/Blue | U | Shadowmoor |
| 194 | Plumeveil | Nils Hamm | White/Blue | U | Modern Masters |
| 218 | Plumeveil | Nils Hamm | White/Blue | U | Ultimate Masters |
| 218 | Plumeveil | Nils Hamm | White/Blue | U | Magic: The Gathering-Commander |
| 65 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Archenemy |
| 143 | Plummet | Filip Burburan | Green | C | Rivals of Ixalan |
| 155 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Modern Masters 2015 Edition |
| 169 | Plummet | Sidharth Chaturvedi | Green | C | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 173 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic: The Gathering—Conspiracy |
| 179 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic 2013 |
| 183 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Masters 25 |
| 184 | Plummet | Aaron Miller | Green | C | Battle for Zendikar |
| 187 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic 2012 |
| 188 | Plummet | Filip Burburan | Green | C | Core Set 2020 |
| 188 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic 2014 Core Set |
| 190 | Plummet | Aaron Miller | Green | C | Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
| 190 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic 2011 |
| 192 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic 2015 Core Set |
| 193 | Plummet | Nicholas Gregory | Green | C | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 193 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Core Set 2019 |
| 194 | Plummet | Bayard Wu | Green | C | Theros Beyond Death |
| 199 | Plummet | Alix Branwyn | Green | C | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms |
| 286 | Plummet | Pete Venters | Green | C | Magic Origins |
| 174 | Plunder | Thomas M. Baxa | Red | C | Time Spiral |
| 158 | Plundering Barbarian | Andrew Mar | Red | C | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms |
| 160 | Plundering Pirate | Francisco Miyara | Red | C | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 37 | Plundering Predator | Lucas Graciano | Red | C | Jumpstart 2022 |
| 57 | Plunge into Darkness | Justin Sweet | Black | R | Fifth Dawn |
| 22 | Plunge into Winter | Vincent Christiaens | White | C | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 161 | Poetic Ingenuity | Kieran Yanner | Red | R | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 377 | Poetic Ingenuity | Kieran Yanner | Red | R | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 82 | Poet's Quill | Anna Fehr | Black | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 305 | Poet's Quill | Anna Fehr | Black | R | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 126 | Pointed Discussion | Jarel Threat | Black | C | Innistrad: Crimson Vow |
| 81 | Pointy Finger of Doom | Martina Pilcerova | | R | Unsanctioned |
| 126 | Pointy Finger of Doom | Martina Pilcerova | | R | Unhinged |
| 80 | Poison Arrow | Li Tie | Black | U | Portal Three Kingdoms |
| 207 | Poison Dart Frog | Julia Metzger | Green | C | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan |
| 238 | Poison Dart Frog | Julia Metzger | Green | C | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 220 | Poison the Blade | Matt Forsyth | Green | C | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate |
| 248 | Poison the Blade | Matt Forsyth | Green | C | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 103 | Poison the Cup | Colin Boyer | Black | U | Kaldheim |
| 193 | Poison the Well | Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai | Black/Red | C | Shadowmoor |
| 57 | Poisonbelly Ogre | Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai | Black | C | Guildpact |
| 288 | Poison-Blade Mentor | Xabi Gaztelua | Black | U | Assassin's Creed |
| 90 | Poison-Tip Archer | Dmitry Burmak | Black/Green | U | Kaldheim Commander |
| 220 | Poison-Tip Archer | Dmitry Burmak | Black/Green | U | Core Set 2019 |
| 256 | Poison-Tip Archer | Dmitry Burmak | Black/Green | U | Bloomburrow Commander |
| Polar Kraken | Mark Tedin | Blue | R | Ice Age |
| 44 | Polar Kraken | Mark Tedin | Blue | R | Masters Edition |
| 198 | Polis Crusher | Chase Stone | Red/Green | R | Theros |
| Political Trickery | Scott Kirschner | Blue | R | Mirage |
| 26 | Pollen Lullaby | Warren Mahy | White | U | Magic: The Gathering-Commander |
| 36 | Pollen Lullaby | Warren Mahy | White | U | Lorwyn |
| 13 | Pollen Remedy | Ben Thompson | White | C | Planeshift |
| 173 | Pollenbright Druid | Matt Stewart | Green | C | War of the Spark |
| 312 | Pollenbright Druid | Matt Stewart | Green | C | Commander Masters |
| 103 | Pollenbright Wings | Terese Nielsen | White/Green | U | Planechase Anthology |
| 103 | Pollenbright Wings | Terese Nielsen | White/Green | U | Planechase 2012 Edition |
| 115 | Pollenbright Wings | Terese Nielsen | White/Green | U | Guild Kit: Selesnya |
| 143 | Pollenbright Wings | Brian Valeza | White/Green | U | Wilds of Eldraine Commander |
| 219 | Pollenbright Wings | Terese Nielsen | White/Green | U | Ravnica: City of Guilds |
| 233 | Pollen-Shield Hare | Olena Richards | White | R | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 293 | Pollen-Shield Hare | Greg Hildebrandt | White | R | Wilds of Eldraine |
| 189 | Polliwallop | Martin Wittfooth | Green | C | Bloomburrow |
| 34 | Polluted Bonds | William Phifer | Black | R | Wilds of Eldraine Enchanting Tales |
| 74 | Polluted Bonds | Michael Sutfin | Black | R | Shadowmoor |
| 75 | Polluted Bonds | 村上ゆいち/YUICHI MURAKAMI | Black | R | Wilds of Eldraine Enchanting Tales |
| 23 | Polluted Cistern | Arthur Yuan | Black | R | Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander |
| 116 | Polluted Dead | Jason A. Engle | Black | C | Avacyn Restored |
| 2 | Polluted Delta | Titus Lunter | | M | Zendikar Rising Expeditions |
| 17 | Polluted Delta | Véronique Meignaud | | M | Zendikar Expeditions |
| 224 | Polluted Delta | Chris Ostrowski | | R | Modern Horizons 3 |
| 239 | Polluted Delta | Vincent Proce | | R | Khans of Tarkir |
| 321 | Polluted Delta | Rob Alexander | | R | Onslaught |
| 356 | Polluted Delta | Vance Kovacs | | R | Modern Horizons 3 |
| 438 | Polluted Delta | Chris Ostrowski | | R | Modern Horizons 3 |
| 465 | Polluted Delta | Chris Ostrowski | | R | Modern Horizons 3 |
| Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Beatdown Box Set |
| Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Battle Royale Box Set |
| 26 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Premium Deck Series: Graveborn |
| 59 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Duel Decks Anthology, Garruk vs. Liliana |
| 59 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Duel Decks: Garruk vs. Liliana |
| 253 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Dominaria Remastered |
| 265 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Commander Anthology |
| 288 | Polluted Mire | Pierre Loyvet | | C | Warhammer 40,000 Commander |
| 300 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Commander 2015 |
| 307 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Commander 2014 |
| 323 | Polluted Mire | Stephen Daniele | | C | Urza's Saga |
| 15 | Pollywog Prodigy | Caroline Gariba | Blue | R | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 50 | Pollywog Prodigy | Caroline Gariba | Blue | R | Bloomburrow Commander |
| 63 | Pollywog Symbiote | Simon Dominic | Blue | U | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 372 | Pollywog Symbiote | Simon Dominic | Blue | U | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 200 | Polukranos Reborn | David Auden Nash | Green | R | March of the Machine |
| 300 | Polukranos Reborn | Jason A. Engle | Green | R | March of the Machine |
| 200 | Polukranos, Engine of Ruin | David Auden Nash | White/Green | R | March of the Machine |
| 300 | Polukranos, Engine of Ruin | Jason A. Engle | White/Green | R | March of the Machine |
| 224 | Polukranos, Unchained | Chris Rahn | Black/Green | M | Theros Beyond Death |
| 43 | Polukranos, World Eater | Karl Kopinski | Green | M | Duel Decks: Heroes vs. Monsters |
| 172 | Polukranos, World Eater | Johann Bodin | Green | M | Theros |
| 65 | Polygoyf | Helge C. Balzer | Green | R | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 117 | Polygoyf | Helge C. Balzer | Green | R | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 99 | Polygraph Orb | Jokubas Uogintas | Black | U | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| Polymorph | Robert Bliss | Blue | R | Mirage |
| 67 | Polymorph | Robert Bliss | Blue | R | Magic 2010 |
| 86 | Polymorph | Robert Bliss | Blue | R | Classic Sixth Edition |
| 90 | Polymorph | Robert Bliss | Blue | R | Ninth Edition |
| 75 | Polymorphist's Jest | Craig J Spearing | Blue | R | Magic 2015 Core Set |
| 90 | Polymorphist's Jest | Craig J Spearing | Blue | R | Commander 2017 |
| 46 | Polymorphous Rush | Ryan Barger | Blue | R | Journey into Nyx |
| 12 | Polyraptor | Yeong-Hao Han | Green | M | Special Guests |
| 144 | Polyraptor | Mark Behm | Green | M | Rivals of Ixalan |
| 171 | Pompous Gadabout | Scott Murphy | Green | U | Murders at Karlov Manor |
| 229 | Pond Prophet | Simon Dominic | Blue/Green | C | Bloomburrow |
| 38 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Jumpstart: Historic Horizons |
| 68 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Magic 2010 |
| 73 | Ponder | Ernanda Souza | Blue | C | Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander |
| 73 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Magic 2012 |
| 79 | Ponder | Mark Tedin | Blue | C | Lorwyn |
| 96 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Commander 2018 |
| 105 | Ponder | Dan Murayama Scott | Blue | C | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander |
| 125 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Commander 2021 |
| 217 | Ponder | Pauline Voss | Blue | C | Doctor Who Commander |
| 229 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | C | Streets of New Capenna Commander |
| 245 | Ponder | Ejiwa "Edge" Ebenebe | Blue | R | Secret Lair Drop |
| 315 | Ponder | Dan Scott | Blue | B | Time Spiral Remastered |
| 63 | Pondering Mage | Tommy Arnold | Blue | C | Modern Horizons |
| 44 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Planar Chaos |
| 62 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Double Masters |
| 79 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Time Spiral Remastered |
| 106 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander |
| 120 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Commander 2014 |
| 190 | Pongify | Heather Hudson | Blue | U | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 27 | Pontiff of Blight | Seb McKinnon | Black | R | Dragon's Maze |
| 33 | Pontiff of Blight | Seb McKinnon | Black | R | Guild Kit: Orzhov |
| 108 | Pontiff of Blight | Seb McKinnon | Black | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 155 | Pontiff of Blight | Seb McKinnon | Black | R | Commander 2014 |
| 768 | Pontiff of Blight | Seb McKinnon | Black | R | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 191 | Ponyback Brigade | Mark Zug | White/Black/Red | C | Khans of Tarkir |
| 28 | Pool of Vigorous Growth | Jokubas Uogintas | Green | R | Jumpstart: Historic Horizons |
| 74 | Pooling Venom | Ron Spears | Black | U | Future Sight |
| 49 | Pop Quiz | Matt Stewart | Blue | C | Strixhaven: School of Mages |
| 71 | Poppet Factory | Simon Dominic | Blue | M | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 339 | Poppet Factory | Simon Dominic | Blue | M | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 71 | Poppet Stitcher | Simon Dominic | Blue | M | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 339 | Poppet Stitcher | Simon Dominic | Blue | M | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt |
| 114 | Popular Egotist | Julia Metzger | Black | U | Duskmourn: House of Horror |
| 192 | Popular Entertainer | Zoltan Boros | Red | R | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 4 | Porcelain Gallery | Chris Cold | White | M | Duskmourn: House of Horror |
| 335 | Porcelain Gallery | Cacho Rubione | White | M | Duskmourn: House of Horror |
| 19 | Porcelain Legionnaire | Eric Deschamps | White | C | New Phyrexia |
| 30 | Porcelain Zealot | Krharts | White | U | Phyrexia: All Will Be One |
| 128 | Porcuparrot | Chris Seaman | Red | U | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths |
| 28 | Pore Over the Pages | Magali Villeneuve | Blue | U | Duel Decks: Blessed vs. Cursed |
| 79 | Pore Over the Pages | Magali Villeneuve | Blue | U | Shadows over Innistrad |
| 86 | Pore Over the Pages | Magali Villeneuve | Blue | U | Shadows Over Innistrad Remastered |
| 28 | Porphyry Nodes | Alan Pollack | White | R | Planar Chaos |
| 32 | Porphyry Nodes | Alan Pollack | White | R | Time Spiral Remastered |
| 90 | Port Inspector | Dan Frazier | Blue | C | Mercadian Masques |
| 265 | Port of Karfell | Mauricio Calle | | U | Kaldheim |
| 280 | Port of Karfell | Mauricio Calle | | U | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander |
| 347 | Port of Karfell | Mauricio Calle | | U | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander |
| 908 | Port of Karfell | Mauricio Calle | | U | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate |
| 33 | Port Razer | Zoltan Boros | Red | M | Special Guests |
| 193 | Port Razer | Craig J Spearing | Red | M | Commander Legends |
| 230 | Port Razer | Craig J Spearing | Red | M | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander |
| 669 | Port Razer | Craig J Spearing | Red | M | Commander Legends |
| 174 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty Commander |
| 178 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Innistrad: Crimson Vow Commander |
| 255 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander |
| 273 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | U | Shadows Over Innistrad Remastered |
| 278 | Port Town | Noah Bradley | | R | Shadows over Innistrad |
| 289 | Port Town | Eliz Roxs | | R | Warhammer 40,000 Commander |
| 294 | Port Town | Alexander Gering | | R | Doctor Who Commander |
| 323 | Port Town | Marina Ortega Lorente | | R | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle Earth Commander |
| 364 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Modern Horizons 3 Commander |
| 419 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | March of the Machine Commander |
| 420 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Streets of New Capenna Commander |
| 507 | Port Town | Alexander Gering | | R | Doctor Who Commander |
| 1019 | Port Town | Kamila Szutenberg | | R | Commander Masters |
| 33 | Portable Hole | John Stanko | White | U | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms |
| 98 | Portable Hole | John Stanko | White | U | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate |
| 13 | Portal Mage | Yongjae Choi | Blue | R | Commander 2017 |
| 112 | Portal Mage | Yongjae Choi | Blue | U | Commander Masters |
| 122 | Portal Mage | Yongjae Choi | Blue | R | Ikoria Commander |