SwordofKaldra: It's not standard, but you could use Flash.
Amazing removal in Blue. This is the truly the set of killing things.
Posted By:
Amnatto
(5/2/2011 6:55:07 PM)
Wow, this has black written all over it, so evil and brutal.
.... wait a minute!!?
Posted By:
Sironos
(5/3/2011 3:27:05 PM)
Question, Say your opponent has a titan out
If you play Might of Oaks on their titan right before you bring this bad boy down, does that mean you get a 16/16?
adversely, say i have a titan and my opponent tries bringing this guy in. In response, can i Dismember my own titan, Turning him into a 1/1 so they end up paying 7 for a 4/4 XD
Basically, I'm wondering if its affect applies to the exiled creature's BASE p/t, or its p/t at the time of being exiled
Posted By:
00bsdude
(5/4/2011 6:10:49 AM)
@00bsdude
If you read what the card says carefully, you'll notice that it says "where X is the exiled creature CARD's power and Y it's toughness".
With wording like that, i'm 99% sure it only looks at the numbers printed in the corner of the card. If it cared about effects that change the p/t of the creature, it would say "where X is the exiled creature's power..." instead referring to the actual card.
Posted By:
Drixy
(5/8/2011 10:36:39 AM)
I'm putting this in my Venser ETB effect deck. This isn't an O-Ring, they don't come back into play when he leaves. Bounce to your heart's content and every time he comes in you remove something else.
Posted By:
TheKeiser
(5/8/2011 5:39:11 PM)
Emrakul? OM NOM NOM
(If I'm not mistaken)
Posted By:
hell_sword2280
(5/9/2011 3:30:33 PM)
@00bsdude
I believe the key word on the card that answers your question is "EXILED", it gains the P/T of the exiled card, which means it's checking the cards stats after it's been removed, an the moment the card was removed it lost any other effects that were on it that could have been altering its stats, and is just it's base stats. If that makes any sense.
either way I like this card ... I happened to get one in a booster on pre-release an my friend got 3 ... an he hates them so I may be getting a play set of them to put in a mana ramp GU deck.
Posted By:
Redgurr
(5/10/2011 5:39:25 AM)
Removal and a (potentially) giant beater wrapped up in one. What is there not to love? Yeah, it's not Titan level, but in my honest opinion, a lot titans feel overpowered. I give it a 5 for being pretty balance in what it does. It's also pretty awesome in limited too. =3
Posted By:
DragoKnight
(5/10/2011 11:17:30 AM)
I saw the 
CMC and thought Geosurge + Island...boy am I not very creative...
Posted By:
jknight05
(5/24/2011 1:42:43 AM)
so, if i exiled a germ token, would he just get +0/+0, or would he get whatever that token's power was at that time?
Posted By:
Torturing101
(5/30/2011 3:10:56 PM)